Court of Petty Appeals: Coal. of Thanks Givers v.Big Protein Ass’n.

Coal. of Thanks Givers

v.

Big Protein Ass’n.

79 U.Va. 11 (2026)

 

Lawson, J., delivers the opinion of the Court, in which Berklich and Wu, C.J.J., and Boatright, Lozada, Moore, Koeppel and Vanger J.J. join.

Lawson, J., delivers the opinion of the Court:

 

Facts

Of all public holidays observed in these great United States, Thanksgiving is perhaps the most emblematic of the nation’s values. No other observance equals the holiday at marrying the traditions of performative displays of gratitude, intergenerational political discourse, historical revisionism, and chowing the frick down with no remorse.

Over the past half-decade, the capricious entity that controls the nation’s collective definition of “healthy eating” has locked onto a new targeted trend: proteinmaxxing. No category of food has been untouched. Pinterest is flooded with high-protein, cottage cheese-centric versions of any conceivable recipe. Quest now makes protein chips, for some reason. Fage 0% fat Greek yogurt has faced periodic nationwide shortages over the last year as demand has exploded.[1] One cannot even swallow a gnat without guestimating its weight in grams for a MyFitnessPal log.[2] The world’s most significant celebration of excessive food consumption has not been spared from the onslaught. One would reasonably predict that a holiday meal centered on the demolition of a ’roided-up hunk of poultry would appease the protein pantheon and warrant a pass-over in their creatine-powered crusade, but alas, ’tis not so.

The action before the Petty Court was brought by the Coalition of Thanks Givers (hereinafter “TG”)—a special interest entity with a mission of preserving the sanctity of good ol’ fashioned American Thanksgiving traditions—against defendants Big Protein Association (hereinafter “BP”), on the grounds that the defendants have unlawfully prevented enjoyment of the “chowing the frick down without remorse” tradition by all citizens of the United States by obstructing the inclusion of any dish on American Thanksgiving dinner tables that does not contain at least 100 grams of protein per 1 oz. serving. Defendants have thereby allegedly created a public nuisance. BP raises two contentions, neither of which this court finds persuasive.

 

Discussion

I. Definition of Nuisance

BP contends that plaintiffs’ definition of public nuisance is entirely too broad, as their behavior has not constituted a true interference with a public right. Defendants assert that attempts at an improvement of public health could not reasonably be considered a nuisance in the traditional sense. We disagree. Past instances of public nuisance claims brought before this court have established that we may, at our discretion, interpret the category of “nuisance” quite broadly. Beyond the traditional idea of an infringement of a public right, nuisances by the Petty definition may include such infractions as annoyances, irritations, roadblocks, and even general japery.[3] Actions which attempt to further the public interest by maximally reducing the occurrences of annoying behavior—despite yielding debatable success[4]—are always welcome in this Court.

 

II. Standing

BP also contends that the plaintiffs lack standing for a private action for public nuisance. For this particular action to be successful, TG must prove that the injury suffered surpasses the injury that would be suffered by the general public.[5] We find that the injury suffered by the turkey-gobblin’ TGs does indeed meet this standard, being distinct in both degree and kind from the injury that the general public would be likely to suffer in the same instance. The meals obstructed by the defendants are no ordinary meals. While every food-consuming person in the country is constantly being blasted with pro-protein, anti-carb, anti-fat, and anti-flavor propaganda, the Thanksgiving meal rises above it all. Judgment has no place at the Thanksgiving table, nor do calorie counters. If your Aunt Brenda side-eyes the mashed potato on your plate, it is within the bounds of Thanksgiving norms to call her a frigid hag and spit on her dog. By targeting the uniquely sacred meals protected by the plaintiffs, BP has, we find, caused a distinct injury.


III. Personal (83% lean)(Non GMO)(Antibiotic Free) Beef

The Court would be remiss to fail to include a description of the personal interests at stake in this case. This justice has, herself, recently co-hosted a potluck-style Friendsgiving observance, which was also subject to the protein pestilence at issue. The non-protein offerings at the feast were, to say the least, abysmal. While crafting a tray of corn pudding for the event, a recipe which already included six eggs,[6] this justice turned away for a moment and returned to find a muscular, goblin-like creature (an agent of Big Protein) adding Vega vanilla-flavor plant-based protein powder to the batter. The creature had clearly been summoned from out of the sink drain by the unforgivable scent of edible food. Once the Friendsgiving meal had begun, it was clear that BP’s agents had been working in households across the entirety of Charlottesville. Ham, chicken, and other gains-building treats abounded, yet nary a vegetable could be found.


Costco beef jerky and a boiled egg. A pathetic excuse for “leftovers.” Photo credit: Author.

Thus our discussion must come to a lesser-known, but foundational facet of the Thanksgiving holiday which has been destroyed by defendant’s conduct: leftovers. In years past, a meal such as the one described would have yielded an elephant’s portion worth of delectable, varied foods to be consumed with waning enthusiasm for the following week. Of course, Big Protein would not be satisfied until all meals were nutritionally optimized. This justice opened her meal prep containers today to find not a tasty treat, but a despicable divine test. No cranberry sauce. No stuffing. Only protein.[7]

 

IV. Conclusion

The despicable nature of the defendants and injury at issue compels us to issue as severe a penalty as may be allowed within our Petty power. Defendants Big Protein are hereby ordered to replace the meals lost through their interference. Additionally, Big Protein members and their gains-goblin agents are indefinitely permitted to only purchase and consume full-fat yogurt, to which they shall add 1 cup of refined sugar and ¼ cup of bacon grease in each instance of consumption.

It is so ordered.



[1] See I couldn’t find any in Costco last month. :(

[2] 0.019847 grams of protein for 0.0002134 grams of fat.

[3] See Court of Petty Appeals: Law Students v. Miller Center, 77 U.Va 6 (2024):  “Petitioners’ public nuisance claim may extend to the Miller Center’s decision to schedule the event for the day after Fall Break. Such inattentiveness to the needs of law students is perfect fodder for this Court.” (emphasis added)

[4] See The Big GroupMe at any hour of any day.

[5] Mark A. Rothstein, Private Actions for Public Nuisance: The Standing Problem, 76 W. Va. L. Rev. (1974).

[6] Approximately 45g of protein.

[7] 46 grams.

Previous
Previous

Hot Bench with Ronald Peterson 

Next
Next

Court of Petty Appeals: People who enjoy hope and happiness & 1L who lost all his teeth v. Daylight Saving Time