Richard Posner, Moral Entrepreneur for Economics, Dies at 87 

Richard Posner, the legal scholar, judge, and public intellectual, died last Tuesday, November 10, 2026, at the age of 87. 

Posner graduated from Yale University and Harvard Law School and started his career at the Federal Trade Commission. He soon became a professor at the University of Chicago Law School. There, he became associated with the work of economists such as Gary Becker and published numerous works on law and economics, including the landmark textbook Economic Analysis of Law. President Ronald Reagan appointed him to the Seventh Circuit in 1981, where his influential opinions were known for thoughtfulness and clear writing. In the latter half of his career, Posner published academic and popular works on such widely varied topics as the federal courts, Bill Clinton’s impeachment, catastrophic risk, and, especially, the nature of judging. He has been described both as the most-cited scholar and the greatest Court of Appeals judge of his era. Posner retired from judging in 2017.  

Posner began as an English major who considered leaving the law to pursue a PhD in literature. He had the sensibility of an aesthete: Moral values rest on intuition and rhetoric, not argument. Posner contrasted “academic moralism,” dry philosophical arguments that do not change anyone’s behavior, with “moral entrepreneurship.” He sought to establish economic analysis as the proper foundation for law through his scholarship, through the force of his personality and writing, and sometimes through sheer outrageousness—most infamously in his paper advocating a market for adoption. The physicist Paul Dirac wrote that after the discovery of quantum mechanics, “it was very easy . . . any second-rate physicist to do first-rate work”; anyone could apply the new theory to “one of the little problems [and] write a paper about it.” Posner was not a second-rate scholar, but he lived at a time when an English major could pick any legal issue, apply economic theory, and publish an article. 

Posner also issued a landmark decision finding a constitutional right to gay marriage, had an abiding interest in supporting pro se litigants, and was unfailingly kind and generous to fellow scholars. He is often viewed as relaxing his free-market views after the 2008 recession, but he was never a doctrinaire right-winger. From the start, he rejected social conservatism and critiqued textualism and originalism.  Posner watched as Democrats as well as Republicans embraced cost-benefit analysis, and although his roots were in the Chicago school, he followed the path of empirical social science. 

Posner once wrote that one part of him wanted to be a “conservative establishment figure” and another part wanted to be a “promethean intellectual hero.”  He wanted to rid the law of silly formalism, mushy sentimentality, the Bluebook, mindless rule-following, self-satisfaction, and bad writing. He advocated a philosophy of judicial pragmatism. Legal rules and texts create reliance interests, but they are often indeterminate; legislatures cannot predict every eventuality. Given all that, appellate judges should strive to promote reasonable results, following common sense and empirical evidence as much as conventional legal materials. 

Posner will be remembered as a groundbreaking scholar, a legislator from the bench, an advocate for reasonableness, a hardhearted economist, a contrarian, a crank, and an eminent judge. He was one of the great characters in American law. 

Author: Jason Vanger ’27, nnk2gn@virginia.edu 

Next
Next

Cummins and Balaji Win 98th Annual William Minor Lile Moot Court Competition